Disney's Rivers of America No More

Preserving Disney Heritage: Why the Rivers of America Still Matter

My husband and I are unabashed theme park enthusiasts. We love the rush of a roller coaster, the glow of a nighttime parade, and the intricate details that show true creativity in every corner of a park. We’re not “Disney loyalists” by any stretch—we appreciate innovation wherever we find it. Yet, the recent announcement that Walt Disney World’s Magic Kingdom may demolish the Rivers of America and Tom Sawyer Island for a potential Cars-themed expansion is deeply troubling. This isn’t just a routine case of “out with the old, in with the new.” It’s the dismantling of a cornerstone of Disney and American history.

For those unfamiliar, the Rivers of America is far more than a simple waterway. It’s a scenic, storybook piece of classic Americana—a tranquil world set apart from the hustle of Main Street and the excitement of Tomorrowland. Originally guided by Walt Disney himself, the winding river and Tom Sawyer Island offer a respite of nature and imagination that perfectly complements the rest of the park’s energy.

Legendary Imagineer Eddie Sato—known for contributions from Disneyland Paris’s Main Street to various Disneyland enhancements—has publicly criticized the proposed demolition. He points out that removing the Rivers of America not only erases nostalgia but also disrupts the emotional balance that Walt Disney himself so carefully cultivated. You need these breathing spaces in a theme park to contrast with the high-intensity “lands,” and Tom Sawyer Island has always provided that calm center amid the excitement.

What makes this decision even more perplexing is that Walt Disney World was specifically built with ample land to expand. Unlike Disneyland in California—where space is notoriously tight—Florida’s resort property has acres upon acres of undeveloped space. Why demolish a beloved, historic section of the Magic Kingdom when you have so many unused parcels available? It feels like sacrificing tradition for the sake of convenience, rather than necessity.

Disney might hope fans will eventually accept this change, but online forums and social media reveal large-scale disappointment. According to Eddie Sato and other former Imagineers, Disney already knows about the backlash and continues forging ahead regardless. Their stance appears to be: “The issue is closed.”

This attitude feels like a stark departure from the Disney we grew up loving, the one that listened to guests and strived for excellence in all its endeavors. If these are the same creative teams who believe it’s acceptable to replace a piece of Walt’s personal legacy in the name of an IP expansion, it’s natural to question the integrity of the final product.

It’s not merely a question of preserving the past; we’re also mindful of Disney’s recent track record in updating iconic attractions. Take Tiana’s Bayou Adventure, Moana’s Journey of Water, and the CommuniCore overhaul in EPCOT—each came with bold concept art and grand promises yet left many fans underwhelmed by the final results:

• Tiana’s Bayou Adventure replaced the iconic Splash Mountain. Early concept art hinted at a lush, deeply narrative retheme, but progress reports show a simplified, budget-conscious reality that may lack the detail and charm of the original.

• Moana’s Journey of Water introduced interactive elements to World Nature in EPCOT but replaced large swaths of classic park design. Many lament that it fails to deliver the wonder promised by its concept illustrations.

• CommuniCore at EPCOT was pitched as a revitalized community hub but so far hasn’t recaptured the imaginative spirit of EPCOT’s early years, prompting concerns it’s a bare-bones compromise instead of a visionary new space.

With Cars potentially rolling into a newly cleared spot in the Magic Kingdom, it’s fair to wonder if this addition will truly match the quality of its concept art—or simply follow a pattern of diluted visions.

As theme park enthusiasts who aren’t strictly Disney die-hards, we recognize that change is part of any park’s evolution. But there’s a world of difference between a thoughtful update and bulldozing something with historical, thematic, and emotional significance—especially when so much land remains unused in Florida. Part of the Magic Kingdom’s charm is its intricate balance: adrenaline-fueled rides complemented by gentler experiences like Mark Twain–inspired boat rides and quiet island exploration.

Eliminating Tom Sawyer Island and its river setting disrupts this careful equilibrium. It also undercuts what Walt Disney envisioned when he created a park dedicated to both celebrating America’s past and imagining its future.

At present, former Imagineers believe the “issue is closed.” That’s discouraging, especially considering Walt Disney World’s vast possibilities for expansion. But Disney history has shown that strong fan pushback can make a difference—at times, the company has rethought or tweaked plans after public outcry. Whether or not that happens here remains to be seen.

For my husband and me, preserving the Rivers of America isn’t about clinging blindly to the past. It’s about retaining a piece of Disney heritage and American folklore that can coexist alongside modern updates—particularly when there is so much unused land just waiting to be developed. We’ll keep hoping that if the Cars expansion is inevitable, Disney at least takes steps to honor the spirit of what it’s replacing and strives to deliver an experience worthy of its legacy.

After all, theme parks should spark our imaginations, celebrating both the nostalgia of yesterday and the excitement of tomorrow. If Disney is truly committed to that ideal, it needs to remember the richness that quiet waterways and leisurely riverboats add to the magic—and that some pieces of history are worth keeping afloat.

###